The executive decision is taken within a structuring, and therefore normative, triple squeeze.
- The overall strategic reality carried by the executive, and the demands that follow from it.
- The density of legislative and regulatory texts, recommendations from authorities, and internal rules adopted by the company, which frame, condition or limit the decision.
- The company's organisational models and habits, which distribute decision-making powers.
The executive thus becomes one pixel among others, while remaining responsible for the whole. Their contribution forms part of the collective image created by the organisation's decisions and actions.
This paradox is the starting point for Lead or Follow's work: under what conditions can the holder of the executive mandate formulate their decision, distribute its realisation and pilot its trajectory, without displacing the other mandate holders?
The distribution of decision rights does not, on its own, resolve the question of piloting the executive decision.
Decide what, exactly?
Decision rights are distributed: each function has a defined scope, defined responsibilities and defined autonomy.
But what was entrusted along with the power to decide? What must its holder answer for, and what may they in turn pass on without giving up the exercise of their own mandate?
Is the executive's decision domain defined with the same precision as that of the other holders?
Who decides what?
The organisation has distributed decision rights, and everyone legitimately exercises theirs. But when these decisions meet, follow one another or run against one another, what becomes of the initial decision?
The proliferation of norms comes with a multiplication of roles, prerogatives, controls and processes. The question is not the legitimacy of these functions, but the way their successive interventions maintain, modify or transform the initial decision, and the moment at which these transformations become the object of an identifiable arbitration.
Decide A. Get B — and see it.
To go furtherCorpus I — The Alternative Centre of Gravity of DecisionCorpus II — The Decision Stripped of Its MarginsOther manifestations
The shift: when decisions become processesSeminar
Seminar
When decisions become processes
A decision made by the executive does not necessarily reach operations in the terms, or with the effects, they intended.
Between the executive decision and its implementation are expert functions, reference frameworks, procedures and decision-making powers distributed across the organisation.
How can the trajectory of a decision be held through these interventions, without neutralising the expertise needed for its implementation or losing sight of the strategy that gave rise to it?
This is the subject of the seminar When Decisions Become Processes.
Discover the seminarPilot what, in fact?
A decision A enters the organisation. What reaches operations may be A, an A modified by an arbitration, or a B that no identifiable decision chose. Piloting consists in organising the conditions under which the decision's trajectory remains observable and open to arbitration.
When A enters the organisation, how can what arrives in operations still be A, rather than a B that no one explicitly decided?
Get A by design.
This architecture is installed and, when a trajectory drifts, repaired. It rests on those who exercise it: the expert functions, whose contribution consists in making constraints intelligible and workable; the mandate holders, N-1 then N-2, who must exercise their own mandate while contributing to the overall trajectory.
PublicationThe Executive Decision Held in the Organisation
To go furtherCorpus III — The Architecture of CommandCorpus IV — The Migration: The Architecture Implemented in the Organisation
Responsible for the whole?
The decision has been formulated, the rights distributed, the functions decide. What remains is the result of the whole. The work starts from the strategy, from what the executive must obtain. It then examines how the mandates, prerogatives, obligations and evaluation criteria of the functions are organised so that decision A keeps its trajectory all the way to operations: the contribution of the functions, then the N-1 and N-2 mandates, their objectives, their responsibilities and the metrics that measure them.
The question is not only who answers for the whole. It is how to organise particular responsibilities so that exercising them actually produces the intended overall result. A function may reach its own objectives and still contribute to an overall result contrary to the trajectory: this may be an effect of the way its objectives, prerogatives and evaluation criteria were built.
To go furtherFunctions in the trajectory — expert functions and mandate holders
Arbitrating day to daySeminar
Day to day, escalations, conflicts between functions and requests for arbitration reach the executive. Their office also includes arbitrations that belong to them without any function submitting them: those that make it possible to hold the trajectory without taking back the decisions entrusted.
Arbitrating at the right level means determining what, in this mass, belongs to the mandate: what matters to the executive in light of the destination they must hold, as much as what the functions consider imperative from their own standpoint. It is neither a matter of enduring escalations nor of taking back the work of N-1s and N-2s, but of knowing when to intervene, on what and how far. This requires obtaining the necessary elements (thresholds, escalations, information) without displacing those who produce them.
The decision pixel serves as an instrument for reading and adjusting. Off: a decision necessary to the exercise of the mandate is no longer taken, or can no longer be. Flickering: the holder intervenes at times, but thresholds, escalations and prerogatives are uncertain. On: they exercise their mandate, have the information and know when to decide, delegate or escalate. Overflowing: a decision belonging to another mandate is taken back, at times with the best of intentions.
These states describe the exercise of a mandate at a given moment, not the worth of the person exercising it. They show how to adjust the intervention: relight what has gone out, steady what flickers, contain what overflows.
To arbitrate is to exercise the share of decision that falls to the mandate holder, and to gauge what the distributed decisions produce together.
A particular situation to examine? Some work can also be carried out directly at The Quinta, starting from a real situation of executive leadership.